A concentrated, or single stock, position occurs when an investor owns shares of a stock that represents a large percentage of their overall portfolio. Usually, a stock that comprises more than 10% of a portfolio is considered an “overweight” or concentrated position and should be carefully reviewed to maintain diversification.
Full Answer
What are the disadvantages of a concentrated stock position?
Apr 15, 2021 · In brief, a concentrated stock position is any large accumulation of stock in one company relative to the investor’s total wealth. Longtime employees, executives, and early investors may end up with a significant percentage of their total investable assets “locked-up” in the one stock, putting them in a concentrated stock position.
How to diversify a concentrated stock position?
Jan 22, 2022 · A concentrated position is an investment strategy that involves holding a large number of shares in one company. Learn about this investing strategy here. An investment firm is said to have a concentrated position in a stock or an asset, if the given stock or asset holding comprises a majority, or substantially large, holding of its portfolio.
Is selling a concentrated stock position a tax-efficient option?
Company Stock: What Is A Concentrated Stock Position? Many corporate and tech employees accumulate a great deal of employer stock via Restricted Stock Units (RSU), Incentive Stock Options (ISO), Non-Qualified Stock Options (NSO) and Employer Stock Purchase Plans (ESPP).
Why is it important to have a concentrated stock holding in one company?
A concentrated, or single stock, position occurs when an investor owns shares of a stock that represents a large percentage of their overall portfolio. Usually, a stock that comprises more than 10% of a portfolio is considered an “overweight” or concentrated position and should be carefully reviewed to maintain diversification. Similarly, a portfolio that holds a small number of …
Basics of Concentrated Positions
An example of a concentrated position is that of a portfolio which has a 51% holding of, say, company ABC’s stock. As a result, approximately half of the portfolio’s net worth is tied to ABC’s stock price. Analysts predict that the upside to ABC’s stock price is tremendous; hence the portfolio could appreciate significantly in price.
Do Concentrated Positions Yield Greater Returns?
Much analysis of concentrated positions returns focuses on their short-term implications and gains. That approach makes sense when you consider the logic of high risk and high rewards. Over the long term, however, well-diversified portfolios, that include multiple asset types across industries, tend to outperform concentrated positions.
Concentrated Position Strategies
Taking a concentrated position may seem like a gamble, albeit one backed by research and information, but it need not necessarily be one. There are various strategies that investors can adopt to minimize risk. Some of them are listed below.
OK. How do you fix it?
If you have a concentrated stock position, you should strongly consider diversifying it. There’s a reason we’ve all heard the saying, “don’t put all your eggs in one basket.” Diversification may mean shelter from the storm.
So what do you do now?
It’s important to know you aren’t alone in this. At Ellevest, we work with you to put together a plan to help take the psychology out of selling your stock and get you diversified — that is, create some protection against that downside.
Why is selling a concentrated stock not tax efficient?
In addition, selling the entire position may not be a tax-efficient option if there have been significant capital gains accrued on the position.
What is a VPF in stock market?
In a VPF transaction, the investor with the concentrated stock position agrees to sell their shares at a future date in exchange for a cash advance at the present date.
How does a completion fund work?
The last method is a relatively straightforward approach to diversify a concentrated stock position. A completion fund diversifies a single position by selling small portions of the holding slowly over time, and reinvests the money to purchase a more diversified portfolio. Contrary to the exchange fund, the investor remains in control of the assets, and can complete the desired diversification within a specified time frame.
Why is a VPF not considered a constructive sale?
At higher stock prices, fewer shares would need to be sold to satisfy the obligation, and vice versa with lower stock prices. This variability is one reason the use of a VPF is not considered a constructive sale by the IRS. The benefit of this approach is the immediate liquidity received from the cash advance.
What is equity collar?
The equity collar method involves the purchase of a long-dated put option on the concentrated stock holding combined with the sale of a long-dated call option. The collar should leave enough room for potential gains and losses, so it is not construed as a constructive sale by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and subject to taxes.
What is exchange fund?
The exchange fund method takes advantage of the fact that there are a number of investors in a similar position with a concentrated stock position who want to diversify. So, in this type of fund several investors pool their shares into a partnership, and each investor receives a pro-rata share of the exchange fund.
Why don't you sell $5 million in one transaction?
The stock position has appreciated significantly over time, and you don't want to sell all of the $5 million in one transaction because of the amount of immediate taxes you would have to pay. Instead, you could choose to sell 15 percent of the position each year, and use the proceeds to diversify into other stocks.
Bull Market Presents Opportunity to Address a Major Portfolio Risk, in our View
In our opinion, concentrated positions present one of the biggest obstacles standing in the way of an investor achieving their long-term investment goals. The most sophisticated financial planning tools and the most capable portfolio management teams cannot insulate an investor from the risks presented by these positions.
What is a Concentrated Position?
The term “concentrated position” could mean different things to different people. We define concentration as any single position that is three or more times larger than an average position in a portfolio.
Why Concentrated Positions Can Be Dangerous
1. Concentrated positions can make portfolios more susceptible to “lightning strikes”: A concentrated position can be like a tall tree in a lightning storm. While this risk may be obvious, what might surprise investors is the frequency at which portfolio “lightning strikes” occur.
What are the risks of a concentrated stock?
Another risk of maintaining a concentrated stock is that the company may underperform over a long period. It could be triggered by anything such as the entire sector falling out of favour, changes in regulation, or even mismanagement of the company.
Why is it risky to own a single stock?
Owning a single stock exposes you to higher volatility. It will be risky if you need to liquidate the stock to raise funds. A higher volatility also means that the chance of your stock selling at a lower value is greater than the chance of it selling for a high value.
What is exchange fund method?
Exchange fund method benefits from the fact that there are a large number of investors in a similar position looking to diversify concentrated stocks. So, in the exchange fund method, several such investors pool their shares into a collaboration where each investor receives a pro-rata share of the fund. It means that the investor now has ...
Why is VPF not a constructive sale?
If the stock prices are high, fewer shares would be sold to satisfy the obligation, and vice versa if the stock prices are lower. This variability is one of the reasons for VPF not being regarded as a constructive sale by the tax authorities. VPF offers immediate liquidity as you would receive cash in advance.
Is concentrated stock a good way to get wealthy?
Stock Trading Articles. 8 Min Read. Last Updated July 23rd 2021. While concentrated stocks might be a good way to get wealthy, it is not ideal for ‘staying wealthy’ because they lack diversification and liquidity. Furthermore, concentrated stocks could pose tax issues too. As a highly concentrated stock position involves high-risk exposure to ...
Can you gift stocks to family members?
Gifting Stock to Family Members. This is a good way to divest some stocks. It works especially well if you gift stocks to children who are now adults. You can gift them stocks to help with a down payment for a house, buying a car, or funding studies.
Can you sell a call option with a higher premium?
Conversely, if you are looking for additional income, you can choose to sell a call option with a higher premium that would result in a net cash flow. But remember that in such a case, the equity collar would limit the value of the stock position between the upper and lower limit over the period of the collar.
What are the core options available to a concentrated stock owner?
JP Morgan’s research succinctly put it, the core options available to a concentrated stock owner are - sell, monetize, diversify, give and hedge. Our take is that there is some natural intersection between these concepts and therefore we have combined sell, monetize and diversify into two overlapping alternatives below due to their varying tax impacts.
How to divest from a concentrated position?
Selling is often the most practical and easiest way to divest from a concentrated position. The simplest approach is to sell a position, realize a likely gain, pay your taxes and move on. Sometimes this simple approach is entirely appropriate, however most investors rarely exit an entire position in one moment. The most common approach is having a sales plan over a period of time - which we often do with clients. Laddering sales over a period of time to manage the price risk and tax consequences is often a reasonable approach from an analytical perspective while also considering the behavioral side of these transactions (i.e. fear of missing out, trading out too soon, etc..). Beware however, that if a concentrated stock position is held by a company insider and they possess enough inside knowledge or are an executive they may often be best served to implement a 10b5-1 plan.#N#Another common strategy is to use call options to hopefully achieve a slight premium for exiting a concentrated position. By using call options at a price that is above the current fair market value of the underlying concentrated position, an owner may be forced to sell/deliver securities to the option holder if certain price points are hit. This does accomplish two things which may be desirable to a holder. First, they are being compensated on the premium for the call options at a minimum. Second, they should use the call option at an exit price they are comfortable with, thus meaning if that price occurs and they have to sell some of their position they are satisfied with the result at that price point. It also takes some of the decision-making out of the investor’s own hand and allows them to stick with a plan. What this strategy does NOT do however is protect on downside risk.#N#Whatever the method of outright sale, it tends to lead to tax considerations that can often deter a concentrated stock holder from looking to sell. Despite the tax impact, due to the volatility of many single stock positions, incurring some taxes to be able to then redeploy the residual capital is often the right decision to protect against catastrophic loss. The tax cost of diversifying properly (as appropriate for a financial plan) is often LESS costly than the risk of being wrong about a concentrated position that then goes against the owner. If done properly, the disposition of a concentrated stock position can then lead to a more focused tax-managed portfolio strategy that is able to take advantage of the dispersion we have so clearly pointed out exists across indexes (see Russell 3000 data above) by implementing tax-loss harvesting strategies. Concentrated positions may have been responsible in helping to create significant wealth in someone’s life, however they can also then become the most likely source of dramatic losses which then naturally puts a financial plan at risk. There is a saying that concentrated wealth may help you become wealthy, but diversification is more likely to keep you wealthy.
What is the capital market?
U.S. capital markets & the U.S economy as a whole is a competitive landscape with constant disruption, new entrants, and opportunities for wealth creation. It is one of the benefits of a capital society that lends itself to encouraging entrepreneurship and risk-taking to meet consumer demands. As a result, our nation consistently ranks towards the top of all metrics measuring the number of wealthiest individuals and entrepreneurs. From the environment of opportunity arises many situations involving concentrated stock wealth. This can be rewarding for owners and shareholders but also creates a dynamic where the risk of business displacement, and therefore dramatic changes in their business’ stock price, is constant. Understanding that the investment landscape and environment in the U.S. is highly competitive is the first key aspect of appreciating the position that concentrated stock wealth can have in someone’s financial plan.
How to understand the ultimate options?
To be able to understand the ultimate options available, one needs to be able to assess what analysis should occur . Decisions will have to be made among several possible options, but in order to assess the options accurately proper analysis must occur. The analysis should start with having a real financial plan that prioritizes competing goals across varying time horizons and displays the resources needed to achieve these goals. As part of this plan, an evaluation of overall risk tolerance and how an investment portfolio may help meet these goals should occur and should consider how concentrated stock should be accounted for. Tax planning and analysis will be a crucial consideration as well as part of the overall analysis of how to best approach managing a concentrated stock position. What something is worth before tax is one consideration, what something is worth after taxes (depending on a variety of different decisions and outcomes) is entirely different. Further, if the concentrated stock position is so material to an individual’s wealth it is often wise to consider estate planning needs as well.
How to have a concentrated stock position?
There are many ways you could have a concentrated stock position including through equity-based compensation, inheritance of a sizeable single stock position and from receiving stock in a publicly traded company as part of the sale of a closely held business.
What is concentrated stock?
One form of concentrated stock is a restricted stock unit (RSU). Companies typically offer employees RSUs held in a brokerage account. Once vested, employees can do what they want with the shares. If you leave the company before you’re vested, you forfeit your shares. RSUs are typically assigned a fair market value and considered income, therefore part of the shares are withheld to cover income taxes.
What does buying a put do?
Purchasing a put gives the investor the right (but not the obligation) to sell stock at a predetermined price. Simultaneously, the investor may sell a call, providing another investor the right to purchase the stock at a predetermined price. The premium earned on the call may be used to offset the cost of the put.
What is a protective put option?
A protective put option provides an investor the right (but not the obligation) to sell all or a portion of his or her shares at a predetermined price. Similar to insurance, if the price of the stock goes up, the value of the option could expire worthless.
What is the most appropriate and simplest means of reducing a concentrated stock position?
A sale of stock is might be the most appropriate and simplest means of reducing a concentrated stock position. Tax considerations, potential market impact, reinvestment of proceeds and timing of sales, however, are all elements for you to consider within the context of a coordinated personal wealth management plan.
What are some examples of outsized positions in a single stock?
As one example, a blue-chip stock could lose its allure abruptly, resulting in a steep price decline. Alternately, for example, a company could experience cyclical swings in profitability, which might cause its stock price to materially deviate from the broader market. And the broad equity market historically has had its own ups and downs.
When is hedging incentive stock option?
Hedging incentive stock options before or shortly after exercise creates a separate and special set of considerations, since hedging during the first year after exercise might be a disqualifying disposition and trigger ordinary income taxes.
