Stock FAQs

how to value stock options pre ipo

by Mr. Bill Ebert Sr. Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

When trying to calculate value of your pre-IPO options, don’t go with the number of shares you have per se, but the percentage of ownership those shares give you in the company. How do you know the percentage of the company you own via pre-IPO stock options? First, find out the number of shares outstanding and its market cap.

Equity value = (diluted common shares outstanding, or DSO) x (price per share). DSO assumes that any options “in the money” are converted into shares and proceeds the company receive from their exercise are used to repurchase shares at the market price.

Full Answer

What are the tips for investing in pre IPO shares?

Sep 15, 2020 · How do you know the percentage of the company you own via pre-IPO stock options? First, find out the number of shares outstanding and its market cap. Calculate company value by the number of outstanding shares multiplied by the price per share. If your startup is doing well, its value can grow rapidly.

Should I exercise my stock options before IPO?

Aug 11, 2021 · One critically misunderstood aspect of pre IPO stock options is time value. All stock options consist of two sources of value. Intrinsic value and time value. Intrinsic value is simply the difference between the strike price and exercise price. The higher the exercise price is above the strike price the more intrinsic value that you have.

How do I invest in pre IPO?

Unlike market capitalization, equity value counts shareholder loans (i.e. preferred stock) into the equation, in addition to common stock. Equity value = (diluted common shares outstanding, or DSO) x (price per share).

What investors should know before buying IPO stocks?

Apr 30, 2021 · Pre-IPO Stock Options Guide For those with stock options as part of their employee compensation package, here are some stock option basics and tax implications to keep in mind as you navigate the possibilities of initial public ... A 409(a) is an independent appraisal of the fair market value (FMV) of a private company’s common stock. Long ...

image

How do you value pre-IPO options?

In a publicly traded company, you can multiply the number of options times the current stock price, then subtract out the number of shares times your purchase price, to get a quick sense of how much the options are worth.

Are stock options worth anything before IPO?

So if you wait to exercise until your company starts the IPO process, it not only gives you the most certainty that your shares will be worth more than your strike price, but it also may allow you to sell your options as soon as possible while still qualifying for the long-terms capital gains tax.

What do you do with pre-IPO stock options?

If the company is pre-IPO, you don't have the option to sell your shares unless you go through a third-party service like EquityZen. If the company just IPO'd, you're likely subject to a 90-180 day lock-up period where you can't sell either.May 27, 2021

How do you value stock options?

The quick way of calculating the value of your options is to take the value of the company as given by the TechCrunch announcement of its latest funding round, divide by the number of outstanding shares and multiply by the number of options you have.Nov 2, 2015

Do options vest at IPO?

Your stock options may be vested or unvested. If you have unvested shares, the IPO usually won't change the vesting schedule – although sometimes the IPO deal involves immediate vesting of options as part of the transaction. If you have vested options, you'll need to determine when to exercise them.Jan 15, 2021

What happens to ISOs When a company goes public?

If you already own stock in a private or pre-IPO company Companies going public with a direct listing bypass the lockup period, meaning employees can sell their stock options right away if they choose. Companies going public via SPAC may have longer lockup periods. A lockup period can range from 90 to 180 days.Aug 8, 2017

Can you exercise options during lockup?

Employees and former employees can exercise during a lockup period, but they can't usually take advantage of cashless exercises or other methods where shares can be used to buy the shares and/or potentially pay any required tax withholding.Aug 6, 2019

What happens to vested stock when you quit pre-IPO?

If you leave before you hit your one year mark, you won't get any equity. If you stay for exactly two years, you vest 2,000 options. You don't vest all 4,000 ISOs until you work at the company for four years. If you leave before then, you forfeit any unvested options.May 1, 2020

What does it mean to be pre-IPO?

What does it really mean to be pre-IPO? Simply that your company is not publicly traded, but may do an offering in the future. However, that is not necessarily a guarantee that the IPO will come soon, or indeed, ever.

What is AMT in tax?

The AMT is a dual tax system, where taxes owed are calculated using both the rules for ordinary income and an AMT calculation. You then pay the higher of the two numbers, AMT or ordinary income. So, by exercising your pre-IPO ISOs, you can potentially increase the overall amount of taxes you owe.

Early Exercise

One way to avoid AMT is to minimize the difference between the strike price and the exercise price. ISOs must be awarded at the current pre IPO stock value. On the day you are granted your ISOs the difference between the strike price and exercise price will be zero. Hopefully, with time, it only goes up from there.

Exercising Before an IPO or an exit

Much like an early exercise, exercising your ISOs before an IPO carries very similar risks. There are two big differences.

Exercising after an IPO or a public exit

There are two big changes when your company becomes publicly traded. First, your choice for exercising your options increases. Second, the amount of risk you take significantly decreases.

Deciding to sell shares from ISOs

There are several scenarios where you may sell before you meet the qualifying disposition.

Capturing Long Term Capital Gains

The lack of a liquid market may prevent you from selling any shares. You may be able to sell them on a secondary market, but it is not always a guarantee, and it may come at a lower price. In addition, you may be aware of an upcoming exit at a higher price point.

Balancing AMT from ISOs

Frequently an equity grant will come with both pre IPO stock options: ISOs and NQSOs. While NQSOs don’t have an added tax benefit like ISOs they are not completely useless when it comes to tax strategies.

Tax Shrink

The first is the tax shrink that you will experience from the number of shares you are promised to the number of shares that you get. When your shares vest some will automatically be sold by your employer to cover some taxes. Unfortunately, it is very unlikely it will be enough to cover all the taxes.

What is equity value?

Equity value is a more precise representation of the “market capitalization” valuation metric that you see quoted next to public share prices. Unlike market capitalization, equity value counts shareholder loans (i.e. preferred stock) into the equation, in addition to common stock.

What is valuation discount?

A valuation discount is generally applied to account for the illiquidity and higher risk profile of a private venture. Generally, on the lower end of the valuation range. Determine a valuation benchmark for past acquisitions of comparable companies. Apply transaction multiples paid to your company metrics.

Why is company valuation important?

Understanding company valuation, either your own or your client’s, is key in your ability to close a good deal. It will affect your investor returns, corporate governance, ability to hire and retain talent, and your ability to raise future rounds. Ultimately, your valuation will end up being the result of negotiations.

Who is Bertrand Bertrand?

Bertrand is a 25-year finance veteran with a true 360 experience, honed as an investment banker, venture advisor, project developer, CFO, and expert witness consultant in international arbitrations. He has advised and partnered on over 100 transactions and investment initiatives totaling over $16 billion. Bertrand is a seasoned problem solver and decision-maker with expert facilitation skills. Bertrand advises on M&A, corporate development, venture growth, project development, and financing.

Why is enterprise value important?

Enterprise value is useful for comparing firms with different capital structures. For early-stage venture valuation, it is very useful as a proxy to a public company, due to public companies having more debt capital within their structures.

What is FCF in finance?

FCF is the cash flow available to capital providers (debt + equity). If positive it can be used for debt service and distribution to shareholders. You generally want to project your FCFs over 5 years. If you budget on a monthly/quarterly basis, consolidate your financials yearly, then expand projections for the outer years.

What is WACC in accounting?

Your WACC should reflect the after-tax return expected by the capital providers (lenders and investors). This blended return is used to discount your FCFs and TV to their present value. The WACC includes the cost of equity (see CAPM method) and the cost of debt. To calculate the cost of equity, you must estimate the Beta for your company. As you do, use the comps you picked for your comparable company analysis and their average capital structures rather than the capital structure of your company.

Stock-Option Awards in Pre-IPO Companies

The economics and tax treatment of stock options is a complicated subject that many employees in private companies apparently do not fully understand. Two types of stock options exist: incentive stock-options (ISOs) and non-qualified stock options (NSOs). Of the two, incentive stock options have somewhat more favorable tax treatment.

Private-Company Stock-Option Financing

In recent years, specialty players have entered the market to provide financing to employees to facilitate the exercise of private-company stock options. Examples include ESO Fund, Liquid Stock, Quid, and Secfi.

Evolution of the Market for Stock-Option Financing

The market for private-company stock-option financing has grown rapidly in recent years. However, industry-wide statistics are unavailable. By some estimates, the average financing size is just over $1 million, with an average term of 13 months.

Company View of Stock-Option Financing

Companies have a mixed reaction to external firms offering stock-option exercise financing to employees. On the one hand, some are wary of third-party vendors trying to “cash in” on employee equity.

Future Evolution of the Market

Finally, it is not clear how changes to markets or changes to tax law might impact the industry going forward. The last decade has witnessed a steady increase in public and private company valuations. This trend has boosted the collateral value of shares that underpin the financial model of stock-option financing.

Why This Matters

Capital providers that finance stock-option exercises in pre-IPO companies have developed a product that meets the tax and personal financial needs of employees.

Exhibit 2: Tax Savings from Early Exercise

Notes: 100,000 options for a hypothetical company with $1 strike price, $3 early exercise price, and $10 IPO price. Assumes personal gross income of $150,000, married filed jointly, California resident, 2021 tax year. Does not include financing costs to fund stock option exercise.

How long can you hold stock after IPO?

Be sure to understand the earliest date at which your stock can be sold as a long-term capital gain. This tax-advantaged rate applies to stock held more than one year. Additionally, two years must have passed since the option to buy those shares was granted. Remember, you may have a post-IPO lockup period during which you will not be able to sell stock. A lockup period is a window of time when company insiders are not allowed to redeem or sell shares of their company. Lockup periods can vary but typically span six months post-offering.

What is incentive stock option?

Incentive stock options (ISOs) are a company benefit that give an employee the right to buy shares at a discounted price, while delaying taxes due until those shares are sold. With non-qualified stock options (NSOs) taxes are due both when you exercise the option (purchase shares) and sell those shares. Another common employee compensation package ...

What is bid ask spread?

In the public stock market, there is a published bid-ask spread for each security throughout the trading day, thus providing a means of valuation for a stock or option. In the private marketplace, the valuation of a company is less clear because it is calculated infrequently.

How long is a stock lockup?

A common strategy is exercising options six months before the IPO, which starts your stock holding period. Assuming a six-month lockup, any stock you sell ...

What is AMT in tax?

If you exercise ISOs be aware of the rules surrounding the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT.) The AMT applies to taxpayers with high income by setting a limit on deductions and exclusions. It helps to ensure that certain taxpayers pay at least a minimum amount of tax.

What is a CPA?

A CPA can typically model your estimated tax liabilities given your unique circumstances. If your windfall is substantial enough, a financial planner and estate attorney will strive to ensure your wealth is preserved for yourself and future generations through proper planning.

Can stock options build wealth?

Stock options can be a powerful wealth-builder. If granted, chances are you have a windfall headed your way. Be sure to have a plan in place regarding the exercise of those options and subsequent sale of stock. There are several considerations that should factor prominently in your decision-making process.

In a startup, it's not how many: it's what percentage

If you calculate what percentage of the company you own, you can see how much your shares could be worth as the company grows.

Annual grants versus new-hire grants in high-tech companies

Each tier in the organization should get half of the options of the tier above it.

Ownership percentages at a liquidity event

As a company prepares for an initial public offering, a merger, or some other liquidity event (a financial moment at which shareholders are able to sell, or liquidate, their shares), the ownership structure typically shifts somewhat.

Why are restricted stock units different from stock options?

Restricted stock units are different than stock options because they don’t require an employee to purchase the shares. Instead, they are given or awarded to employees. RSUs are becoming increasingly popular because they are easier to administer and simplify the process for employees also.

What is public traded stock?

Publicly traded stocks listed on an exchange have a clear value, determined by the market each day. They are also typically very liquid. Shares can be sold and redeemed for cash rather quickly. Private companies work with valuation experts to get a fair market value, which is only done periodically throughout the year.

What is Darrow Wealth Management?

Darrow Wealth Management is a fee-only financial advisory firm. We regularly work with employees and executives with stock options, particularly after an IPO or acquisition. By integrating financial planning with investment management, our goal is to help busy professionals build and grow their wealth. As an independent full-time fiduciary, we have a duty to act in the sole benefit and interest of our clients. This is the highest act of loyalty, trust, and care under the law.

Does Darrow Wealth Management provide tax advice?

Darrow Wealth Management offers Private Wealth and Asset Management to individuals and families. This article should not be misconstrued as personalized financial, investment, tax or legal advice. Darrow Wealth Management does not provide tax or legal advice; for inquiries regarding your personal tax or employment situation, consult a CPA or employment attorney in your area.

Can you change your vesting schedule?

There is typically no change to your vesting schedule. Once your shares vest (assuming you are past the lock-up period) you can look at the market price of the stock vs the exercise (or strike) price of your options. This can help you determine if you want to exercise or not.

image

1 – How Do Pre-Ipo Incentive Stock Options Work?

Image
Most of the stock option explanations you’ll find online and in textbooks assume that the company’s stock is publicly traded. With a public market, you can easily compare the exercise price of your incentive stock options to the current trading price of your company’s stock to get a good estimate of what your options are wo…
See more on zajacgrp.com

2 – Is There An IPO Date in The Near Future?

  • What does it really mean to be pre-IPO? Simply that your company is not publicly traded, but may do an offering in the future. However, that is not necessarily a guarantee that the IPO will come soon, or indeed, ever. When doing your financial planning, you should take into account the possibility that an IPO may come later than expected, if at all. More and more frequently compan…
See more on zajacgrp.com

3 – What If The IPO Is Late

  • If you choose to exercise pre-IPO, you will own shares of a non-public company. In some ways this is similar to owning shares of a public company, but there are some important differences. For example, while you may be able sell your shares to another party, some instances it may not be easy to do so. Some plans may not allow for the sale of pre-IPO shares at all. If you are allowed t…
See more on zajacgrp.com

4 – Are You Prepared For A Lockup period?

  • Once an IPO takes place, sale of your shares will likely become much easier, and pricing more transparent. However, you should be prepared for a lockup period that may restricts sale of stock. During this period, often 6 months post IPO, you may not be able to sell your shares of stock per the agreement your company has with an investment bank (the company helping your firm go p…
See more on zajacgrp.com

5 – What Are The Tax Implications of A Pre-Ipo Exercise?

  • While taxes are always important to take into account when considering the timing of exercising your incentive stock options, it’s an especially crucial consideration for pre-IPO companies. Why? Because these shares can be more difficult to liquidate, meaning you may incur a tax liability upon exercise without being able to sell some of the shares you purchased to pay your tax bill. The ta…
See more on zajacgrp.com

6 – Advantages of A Pre-Ipo Exercise of Incentive Stock Options

  • Despite the tax issues discussed above, there can be considerable advantages to pre-IPO option exercise. Many employees of pre-IPO firms are hopeful that there could be substantial stock appreciation in the years following an IPO. If this turns out to be the case, then exercising in the pre-IPO period can have tax advantages in the long run. For ISOs, exercising early can help to lim…
See more on zajacgrp.com

What Now with Your Pre-Ipo Incentive Stock Options

  • Any incentive stock option exercise decision should also be considered alongside your other financial planning needs. But as you can see, the unique issues associated with pre-IPO option exercises make careful planning especially urgent. While there may be several advantages to a pre-IPO exercise such as a lower AMT bill or the start of your qualifying disposition holding perio…
See more on zajacgrp.com

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9